Council Decision – Annexation Note

Good Afternoon WORA members, we hope this note finds you well.

There was a lot of activity this week on the issue of the Barrie Annexation proposal for Oro-Medonte and Springwater Township lands.

On Tuesday evening there was a Special Council meeting in O-M to pass a motion and to vote on the proposal. Jane Voorheis who has been a true champion in representing the voices of a significant number of Oro-Medonte residents including WORA members made yet another deputation in an effort to have our collective voices heard and to ensure Council was clear that we were opposed to the plan. In a very emotional, professional and respective way, Jane proposed that residents of O-M would only support our Council in voting to support the Barrie Annexation proposal if some specific conditions were included.

We are sharing a link to the Township website (first one below) which provides a history of this proposal including an update at the most recent Nov. 4, 2025 Special Council Meeting.

We would strongly encourage you to take a few minutes to review this information as it is very comprehensive and extremely informative. There are 3 embedded links in the latest update which provide the relevant information:

  1. Council Motion that was passed at the meeting.
  2. Staff Report of the Restructuring Proposal including a copy of the Draft Agreement and
  3. The Township YouTube livestream recording of the Special Council Meeting of Nov. 4th.

We wish to acknowledge and to thank the Township staff and Council for navigating through a very difficult, frustrating and challenging facilitation process mandated by the province. This was a ‘no-win’ situation and the objective was to provide the province the feedback received from the residents on the proposal and to negotiate the best outcome possible recognizing that Annexation would in all likelihood proceed. The Staff Report is excellent as it provides a very thorough summary of all the facts in the step by step process.

Despite all the good intentions however, there is disappointment and frustration with the final position taken by Council.

This sentiment is captured in Jane’s note below that she shared following her deputation at the meeting. We would also suggest you hear her deputation in the YouTube livestream recording in the 3rd embedded link (above). Jane was absolutely amazing in delivering her very emotional comments.

https://www.oro-medonte.ca/living-here/community-information/city-of-barrie-boundary-expansion-request/

We are also sharing a link to a recent article in the Barrie Examiner which summarizes the outcome of the County of Simcoe Special Meeting held earlier in the day on Tuesday, November 4th. It is very hard to argue against the sentiment expressed by the County Warden when he stated that “quite frankly, it hasn’t been a facilitation – it’s been a dictatorship from Day 1”.

https://www.barrietoday.com/local-news/unfortunate-quagmire-barries-annexation-plan-gets-conditional-ok-from-county-11442940

While the County of Simcoe and Oro- Medonte both approved the Annexation Proposal in the end, the difference in their approval is worth highlighting. In the case of the County, their approval was conditional on some key requirements, whereas the Oro-Medonte approval has no conditions attached. Instead, O-M Council chose to include some ‘considerations’ that they hope once communicated to the Facilitator and Minister will be included.

Sincerely,

The WORA Executive


Note from Jane Voorheis following her deputation

Dear Friends of the Future and WORA members:

I am deeply saddened by the Council’s decision last night regarding annexation. After two years of standing firm against Barrie’s annexation of Oro-Medonte lands, our Council has now pivoted — not to a conditional “yes,” but to a full “yes,” to the City of Barrie and another “yes” dressed up with vague considerations for our Minister of Housing, Mr. Flack, to think about.

I believe there is a world of difference between conditions that protect our residents and considerations that merely sound thoughtful. Considerations don’t bind anyone; they don’t shape outcomes. It’s like asking whether to wear green or red — a choice with no real consequence.

Council should have said a conditional yes — with clear, enforceable terms to be met. Terms that secured the land’s intended use, protected our community’s buffers and environmental lands, and upheld our local autonomy.

Last night’s decision feels like a difficult step for our group and many Oro-Medonte residents who hoped their voices would truly shape the outcome. I’m not sure they did — at least not in the way we had hoped. Still, we can take some solace in knowing that our collective efforts made a difference: the map was adjusted slightly along the southern Line 1 border and northern border, even though the southern boundary near Baycrest was unfortunately expanded.

Yet even in this disappointment, I want to speak directly to all of you who have stood together over these past two years. I know it has been a long and challenging road — but today, I want every single group member here to feel deeply proud. You have shown what true community spirit looks like.

Your voices, your actions, and your steadfast commitment have reminded everyone that Oro-Medonte is more than boundaries or bylaws — it’s a place defined by its people. You’ve proven that when our community stands together, we do so with heart, courage, and integrity. And while this outcome is disappointing, our unity and spirit remain stronger than ever.

With heartfelt thanks,

Jane