Hello WORA Members – Happy Halloween!
We wanted to share a recent update from Jane Voorheis and the Friends of the Future on Annexation of Oro-Medonte lands by the City of Barrie.
We wish to also advise that the WORA Executive is in full support of the Compromise Proposal Recommendation being made below and hope that Council will endorse it next Tuesday at Council Meeting.
GO JAYS GO!
Sincerely,
The WORA Executive
Update from Jane Voorheis, Friends of the Future (October 30, 2025)
Dear Friends, (with a heavy heart and resolve)
Over the past two years, we, as a community, have watched this annexation process unfold with the hope that facilitation by the Province would lead to a fair, balanced, and mutually beneficial outcome — one that respected both Oro-Medonte and Barrie.
Unfortunately, in my opinion, this has not happened. Despite a pause in our township council’s voting two weeks ago and the facilitator’s desire to meet with all parties one last time, we are once again presented with the same proposal from Barrie that was before us two weeks ago — unchanged, unbalanced, and unresponsive to Oro-Medonte’s concerns.
At the same time, we have to recognize the broader context we’re in. Saying no outright could be seen as a lack of cooperation, and might invite the Province to step in to impose this proposal as a final solution — as we’ve seen happen before to Innisfil lands. It could also risk Oro-Medonte being viewed as obstructionist if Barrie’s growth needs aren’t addressed collaboratively.
But saying yes, under the right conditions, could align with the Province’s goals for regional coordination and help maintain goodwill with the Province. That approach allows us to protect Oro-Medonte’s long-term interests while still participating constructively in regional planning.
However, residents should be very concerned about one critical part of this proposal — the statement that there would be “no immediate land-use changes.” While that might sound reassuring, it means that once these lands shift municipal jurisdiction, Oro-Medonte will no longer have authority over how they’re used. All future planning and development approvals will occur under Barrie’s jurisdiction once the lands are transferred.
That means Barrie — not Oro-Medonte — will ultimately decide what gets built there. And this is exactly why we need firm guarantees that these lands will remain residential and community-focused only, and will never be rezoned to industrial or heavy commercial use. Without that assurance, Oro-Medonte residents could see major changes at their doorstep, with no say in the outcome.
So, rather than simply rejecting this annexation proposal that has been put before us, I believe it’s time for Oro-Medonte to put forward our own offer — one that supports growth and cooperation, but also SAFEGUARDS the identity and integrity of our township.
As residents of this township I believe the majority of us are against losing control of our future. Therefore, it is my opinion now, Oro-Medonte’s position should be yes to annexation ONLY if the following conditions are formally included — either by amendment or Ministerial Order:
- Zoning protection — The annexed land must be for housing and community use only, and must never be rezoned industrial or heavy commercial. The Province of Ontario has the authority under Section 47 of the Planning Act to issue a Minister’s Zoning Order (MZO) that can secure this condition permanently. An MZO can control how land is used and prevent future rezoning, ensuring that the land remains strictly for residential and community purposes — protecting Oro-Medonte residents long after the transfer occurs.
- Annexation freeze — A minimum 30-year pause on any further annexation of Oro-Medonte lands. Our borders deserve stability.
- Residential buffer — A larger buffer zone near existing homes, particularly around Baycrest Circle, to protect residents from urban encroachment.
- Environmental protection — The lands along the 5/6 Sideroad and Line 1 South must remain in Oro-Medonte and retain their current environmental zoning and be protected.
- Adjusted boundary line — The northern boundary of Barrie’s request must be redrawn south to the 5/6 Sideroad, consistent with Barrie’s own stated need of 500 hectares by 2051. The current combined request to Oro-Medonte and Springwater exceeds that by 50 hectares, so Oro should adjust its offer accordingly.
I believe that these conditions are fair, reasonable, and rooted in data and respect. They protect our residents, our environment, and our financial integrity — while still allowing Barrie to grow responsibly.
Facilitation may not have succeeded with its goal of “a mutually beneficial outcome for all parties” — but our resolve, our unity, and our respect for this land have not. I would like this to be the moment Oro-Medonte takes back the conversation and leads with fairness, foresight, cooperation and pride.
Please let me know your thoughts,
With resolve,
Jane Voorheis
PS – I have put out a “missing person” alert for MPP Doug Downey!!!!